Record Details

Limitations of using simple indicators for evaluating agricultural emission reductions at farm level — evidence from Kenyan smallholder dairy production

CGSpace

View Archive Info
 
 
Field Value
 
Title Limitations of using simple indicators for evaluating agricultural emission reductions at farm level — evidence from Kenyan smallholder dairy production
 
Creator Luedeling, Eike
Whitney, Cory
Wilkes, Andreas
Aynekulu, Ermias
Rosenstock, Todd S.
 
Subject livestock
monitoring and evaluation
mitigation
ganado
seguimiento y evaluación
mitigación
 
Description National-scale carbon footprints of livestock production are commonly computed from a set of production system
characteristics that serve as inputs for greenhouse gas (GHG) emission models. We evaluated the feasibility of
using such equations at a finer scale to derive a simple farm-scale indicator of emission intensity (milk yield per
head). Using probabilistic simulations, we quantified the impact of input variable uncertainty on emission estimates
for smallholder dairy farms in Kenya. We simulated emissions for farm-scale scenarios generated from a survey of
414 households and published or expert-estimated uncertainty bounds. We simulated the impacts of five
interventions: changing breeds, retiring unproductive males, keeping fewer replacement males, feeding forage
supplements, and balancing animal diets. Impacts were assessed against a true counterfactual and against a more
realistic scenario affected by random effects. We estimated errors incurred in classifying farms into adopters and
non-adopters of the innovations based on changes in milk yield per animal. Given the current uncertainty, such
classification would either miss a large percentage of adopters or misclassify many non-adopters as adopters. As a
critical uncertainty, we identified the milk yield of dairy cows. Added precision on this metric reduced but did not
eliminate classification errors. We remain cautiously optimistic about using milk yield per head to proxy emission
intensity, but its effective use will require further reduction of critical uncertainties. Replacing generic
recommendations of parameter uncertainties with context-specific error estimates might lead to a more efficient quantification of the carbon footprint of milk production on smallholder farms.
 
Date 2022-09-08
2023-01-13T15:20:39Z
2023-01-13T15:20:39Z
 
Type Journal Article
 
Identifier Luedeling, E.; Whitney, C.; Wilkes, A.; Aynekulu, E.; Rosenstock, T.S. (2022) Limitations of using simple indicators for evaluating agricultural emission reductions at farm level — evidence from Kenyan smallholder dairy production. Carbon Footprints 1(9) 21 p. ISSN: 2831-932X
2831-932X
https://hdl.handle.net/10568/127070
https://doi.org/10.20517/cf.2022.11
 
Language en
 
Rights CC-BY-4.0
Open Access
 
Format 21 p.
application/pdf
 
Publisher OAE
 
Source Carbon Footprints